What two different stances do students take regarding climate change solutions?
Click to see answer
They contextualize problems and solutions by addressing the individual, either 'myself' or 'someone else'.
Click to see question
What two different stances do students take regarding climate change solutions?
They contextualize problems and solutions by addressing the individual, either 'myself' or 'someone else'.
What age group of students was studied in the research?
14 years old.
What has previous research revealed about morality and socio-scientific issues?
There is a close relation between morality and socio-scientific issues, advocating the need for addressing ethical aspects in science education.
What aspect of students' moral reasoning is highlighted in the findings?
Students are often unaware of their varying considerations for others, the environment, and society.
According to the discussion, who should consider the results of their actions?
Individuals themselves.
How do students' proposed actions differ based on the identity of the factory owner?
They vary depending on whether the owner is 'myself' or 'someone else'.
What emotional response did Huang express regarding environmental damage?
He felt sad about the damage to the environment, as it is his homeland.
What do students identify as main problems causing climate change?
Emissions from cars and factories.
What measures did the students propose to address environmental damage?
They suggested installing environmentally sound equipment and correcting drainage to meet national standards.
What do the students associate with the irresponsible behavior of factory owners and staff?
Their low makings.
What is the main focus of the research reported in the paper?
Students' interpretations of climate change from a moral perspective.
What research method was used in the study?
Semi-structured group interviews.
How does Li respond to concerns about the impact on workers if factories are closed?
Li suggests that workers would go to farms, showing insufficient consideration for their livelihood.
What reason does Dong give for wanting a bigger car?
He thinks a big car is more comfortable.
What do recent findings suggest about students' expression of personal views on environmental issues?
Students may not express their personal views when discussing environmental problems with teachers.
What is the implication of the study for practice and research?
The paper discusses implications for improving understanding and teaching of moral reasoning in relation to climate change.
What dilemma is highlighted in relation to economic development and environmental conservation?
The challenge of reducing poverty while conserving the environment and natural resources.
In which journal was the article 'Climate Change and Morality' published?
International Journal of Science Education.
What is the relationship between socio-scientific issues and ethical issues?
Socio-scientific issues involve ethical considerations and moral judgments through social interaction.
What area of research is suggested to be further investigated?
Students' moral reasoning and development.
What does the traditional Kohlbergian model of moral development propose?
It proposes universal moral stages through which people progress in moral reasoning.
What assumption do students make about factory owners' morality?
They assume that factory owners have low morale.
What concept is emphasized by the students regarding factory owners?
The importance of inner drive and self-discipline.
What was the age and grade of the students involved in the study?
14 years old and in seventh grade.
What does Li reveal about his true preference for a car?
He would actually prefer a very grand and gorgeous car to show off.
What abilities are important for students when confronted with scientific and moral dilemmas?
The ability to make informed decisions when faced with multiple perspectives.
What has been stressed as part of 'scientific literacy'?
Students' understanding of the nature of science and argumentation skills.
What aspect was coded when students talked about individual actions?
Individual.
Who are the authors of the article 'Climate Change and Morality'?
Li Sternäng & Cecilia Lundholm.
What was the initial stance of Group 2 regarding factory emissions?
They proposed that the government should forcibly shut down the factories.
What is 'contextual awareness' in socio-scientific education?
The ability to understand the complexity and dilemmas faced in solving environmental problems.
What has been less explored in research on students regarding socio-scientific issues?
Students' values and moral reasoning.
How do students' considerations for improving nature depend on their perspective?
It depends on whether they consider themselves or others taking action.
Where were the students studying in the research?
Green Schools in the Beijing area, China.
What common perspective did the three students share regarding environmental responsibility?
They grounded their arguments on personal needs rather than environmental and social concerns.
What do the students imply about individuals with high makings?
They will be more responsible for the environment.
How were the interviews recorded?
On a digital recorder by the interviewer.
Why was the term 'climate change' used in the paper instead of EGHE?
Because 'climate change' and 'global warming' are more commonly used in science education literature.
What does the interviewer suggest when asking 'Do you mean what you say?'
It hints that the student might be insincere about their environmental claims.
What role do students attribute to society when the polluter is 'someone else'?
A controlling and punishing role.
What is the main focus of the article 'Climate Change and Morality'?
Students' perspectives on the individual and society regarding climate change.
Why is it important for teachers to address moral and societal aspects in education?
To equip students as future decision-makers.
What was a key finding regarding students' environmental solutions?
Many excluded natural aspects when considering solutions from 'individual as self'.
How does the audience affect students' reasoning about car purchases?
Students may choose environmentally friendly cars when considering the interviewer as a teacher, but may opt for larger cars outside of that context.
What did Levine (1979) find about moral development stages?
New stages build upon old ones rather than replace them, encompassing previous elements.
What does Li believe will happen if factories are shut down?
The greenhouse effect will be reduced and nature will gradually restore.
How do students view the role of the government in addressing factory issues?
They resort to the government for solutions, indicating a reliance on external authority.
What was the main focus of the interviews conducted with the students?
To investigate their knowledge about the enhanced greenhouse effect (EGHE) and their views on solutions to climate change.
How do the students' discussions reflect their views on environmental issues?
While they mention environmental concerns, their true preferences often lean towards larger, more luxurious cars.
What method was used for qualitative analysis in the study?
Intentional analysis.
What are the four components of the Green School programme?
Green education, green management, green school environment, and green life in the community.
What were identified as major causes of climate change in the Chinese context?
Emissions from cars and factories.
What was the purpose of the analysis conducted by Sternäng and Lundholm?
To clarify different reasoning on proposed solutions.
What does the study suggest about context-free moral reasoning?
The study indicates that context-free moral reasoning is not demonstrated, as students reason differently based on the situation.
What is a social dilemma in the context of environmental issues?
A social dilemma occurs when individuals prioritize their private interests over the common good, leading to conflicts between personal and collective benefits.
What responsibility do students attribute to factory staff and owners?
They believe factory staff and owners should consider and address emissions themselves.
What did Grace and Ratcliffe (2002) reveal about students' decision-making?
Students' arguments were often based on values and ethical considerations rather than scientific knowledge.
Who do the students believe should take legal responsibility for environmental issues?
Factory owners and staff.
What do the students suggest as a solution for pollution from factories?
Only allow those who do not pollute to run the factory.
What was the students' stance on shutting down factories?
They all agreed that the factories would definitely not be shut down.
What role did the students believe technology would play in solving environmental problems?
They implied that technology is the means to solve environmental problems.
Why were Chinese students chosen for the study?
Due to China's rapid economic development and deteriorating environment.
How does the identity of the individual affect students' moral reasoning?
When 'myself', they are more anthropocentric; when 'someone else', they show concern for the environment.
What is essential for achieving scientific literacy in socio-scientific issues according to Zeidler and Lewis?
The development of an ethical framework must be included in teaching.
What controversial aspects have been missing in teaching socio-scientific issues?
Moral, social, and societal aspects.
What do students prioritize in their discussions about purchasing cars?
Students prioritize personal needs over environmental concerns, with some preferring big cars and others smaller, more eco-friendly options.
What is the DOI for the article 'Climate Change and Morality'?
10.1080/09500693.2010.503765.
What major threat has climate change been identified as?
One of the nine major threats with potentially irreversible results for the planet.
What do students believe environmental protection agencies should do regarding CO2 emissions?
Inspect factories and manage emissions.
What did Harré (1984) advocate instead of Kohlberg's stages?
A theory of moral order, suggesting heterogeneous moral judgments based on different dilemmas.
What is suggested as a key to improvement in environmental responsibility?
Raising consciousness about responsibility.
How did Li plan to finance environmental corrections if funds were insufficient?
He would apply for a loan.
What support is needed for ethical reasoning in climate change education?
Support for both teachers and students.
What language was the interview transcribed into before translation?
Chinese.
What is the aim of the Green School programme initiated in 1996?
To enhance schools' environmental management and education.
How many students participated in the study and what were their demographics?
Nine students (four boys and five girls) from three Green Schools with different socio-economic backgrounds.
What is essential for adopting a pro-environmental and sustainable lifestyle?
Changing behavior and taking environmental actions.
Who conducted the interviews and why?
A biology teacher from a university in Beijing, due to her willingness and biological expertise.
What aspect did students focus on when discussing solutions to climate change?
The aspect of individual responsibility.
What has recent research focused on regarding students' understanding of climate change?
Students' difficulties and deficiencies in natural scientific understanding.
How do students view the role of individual workers in environmental change?
They emphasize the importance of consciousness among individual workers.
What did Sadler (2004) investigate regarding moral sensitivity?
Its contribution to decision-making, finding that both moral and non-moral aspects were considered.
What is Li's stance on small factories that do not install environmentally sound equipment?
They should be forcibly shut down by the government.
What environmental concern is mentioned in the discussion about car preferences?
Carbon dioxide emissions from factory chimneys and car exhaust.
What is the main point Wang emphasizes for change?
Self-consciousness of the factory owner.
What does Li initially claim about his car preference?
He claims he would buy a small car for ease of driving and less pollution.
What concept was consistently used throughout the group interviews?
Enhanced greenhouse effect (EGHE).
What model was used to analyze students' reasoning on solutions?
A triangular model encompassing individual, nature, and society.
What type of questions were included in the interviews?
Questions about the natural scientific concept of EGHE, its causes, and solutions.
What was the purpose of presenting a picture of a degraded city environment at the beginning of the interview?
To prompt students to describe what happened and relate it to pollution.
What dilemma do individuals face regarding personal dreams and environmental responsibility?
Choosing between fulfilling personal dreams and taking responsibility for environmental protection.
What should a vision of scientific literacy consider according to Zeidler and Lewis?
The human and social context of science, including moral reasoning.
Why is it important to consider the social setting in the analysis?
To facilitate an empirically grounded analysis that considers cognitive and discursive aspects.
What role does the government play in the students' discussion about responsibility?
They believe the government should help raise the makings of individuals.
What type of car do Chen and Zhang prefer?
They prefer small cars.
What influences students' decision-making patterns according to Sadler?
How hypothetical issues are presented, either as a third person or in a personalized way.
What aspects do students consider when discussing societal institutions?
Internal aspects like conscience and moral drive, and external aspects like legislation.
How did the interpretation of 'individual' affect students' views on responsibility?
If interpreted as someone else, students had different views on necessary actions and responsibility.
What were the four steps of coding students' utterances in the analysis?
What is essential for understanding socio-scientific issues according to the study?
Students' degree of scientific literacy.
What kind of follow-up questions did the interviewer ask?
Questions that challenged students' statements and encouraged elaboration on problems and solutions.
What do students believe is the reason for problems with factories?
They believe it is due to the factory owners' low morale.
What did Li, Huang, and Fang prioritize when discussing the closure of their factory?
They prioritized earning money and the difficulty of shutting down the factory.
How does moral reasoning develop according to research?
It does not develop in stages; individuals may hold different views simultaneously.
What criticism do neo-Kohlbergians have regarding the classical Kohlbergian theory?
They disapprove of its structural homogeneity and argue for a more flexible understanding of moral judgments.
What does 'consciousness raising' refer to in the context of the discussion?
Waking individuals up to their responsibility.
What personal needs do students highlight when discussing car purchases?
Comfort and vanity.
What societal aspect was coded in the analysis of climate change discussions?
Society.
How were the interviews structured?
Three students from the same school formed one group and were interviewed together.
What realization did Li have during the interview?
He realized it was not an exam and the interviewer was not grading his answers.
What environmental concern is raised regarding car ownership in China?
Increased CO2 emissions from driving cars harm the environment.
How did students' interpretations of 'individual' differ?
As 'individual as self' and 'individual as others'.
What skills are required for students to handle socio-scientific problems?
The ability to identify different perspectives and contexts.
What is the focus of increasing studies in socio-scientific issues?
Improving argumentation skills and the use of scientific content knowledge in decision-making.
What solution does Wang propose for filtering emissions?
He suggests that environmental protection agencies should install filters.
What factors did Carpendale and Krebs (1992) identify as important in moral reasoning?
Culture and audience.
What does the study focus on regarding students and climate change?
Students' moral considerations and reasoning when suggesting and deciding on actions against climate change.
What was the duration of each interview conducted by L. Sternäng and C. Lundholm?
50–60 minutes.
What cooperative relationships were highlighted in the students' discussion?
They mentioned the supportive roles of the government and foreign countries.
What initial response did Li give during the interview?
He likely wanted to please the interviewer by giving the 'morally correct' answer.
What do students often fail to recognize in their reasoning about environmental action?
They are unaware that different 'principles' for taking action are used, allowing them greater freedom and comfort.
What major greenhouse gas did students identify in the discussions?
CO2.
How do students' moral reasoning differ when considering themselves as the factory owner versus others?
If the factory owner is 'me', personal interest is stressed and support from the government is expected; if it's someone else, nature is prioritized, and punishment is advocated.
What aspects are increasingly acknowledged in environmental education research?
Affective aspects, particularly moral aspects of environmental issues.
How did Group 2's perspective change when considering the factory owner's viewpoint?
They expressed reluctance to close the factory, prioritizing personal financial gain.
What was the response of Group 2 when asked if they would close their factory due to environmental harm?
They expressed that they would not close it, citing financial reasons.
What did Öhman and Östman (2007) find regarding students' prior experiences?
They played a part in the process of moral meaning-making.
What gap does environmental research indicate?
A gap between scientific knowledge and pro-environmental actions.
What was the focus of the analysis regarding environmental issues?
Different aspects and relationships between individual, society, and nature.
What is a social dilemma in the context of environmental education?
Students' views on solutions to issues like climate change.
When was the article 'Climate Change and Morality' published online?
10 September 2010.
What does the term 'socially desirable' imply in moral reasoning?
It implies that individuals may present what they believe is acceptable or favorable in social contexts, adjusting their reasoning based on the audience.
What concern does Zhu express about environmental protection agencies?
She worries that they may not be able to catch factory owners discharging emissions.
What was the focus of the project investigating Chinese secondary students?
Their conceptions of climate change, including scientific understanding and views on solutions and actions.
