What is the focus of Chapter 3?
Click to see answer
The Psychology of Police Investigations.
Click to see question
What is the focus of Chapter 3?
The Psychology of Police Investigations.
What is one potential problem with the Reid Model?
Deception detection.
What is another issue associated with the Reid Model?
Investigator bias.
What do police need to conduct interrogations?
A viable suspect in custody.
How can false confessions affect other evidence in a trial?
They may taint other evidence, making it appear more corroborative than it really is.
What type of interrogations can lead to false confessions in the Reid Model?
Coercive/suggestive interrogations.
When is identifying probable suspects relatively straightforward?
When the victim and offender know each other and there is a clear motivation for the crime.
What is geographic profiling?
A technique used to analyze the locations of a series of crimes to determine the likely area of the offender's residence.
What is a consequence of police receiving a false confession?
They may be diverted down a false trail, wasting valuable time.
What is the first point in the Supreme Court of Canada's framework for determining the voluntariness of a confession?
The Court must consider whether the police made any threats or promises.
What is a major issue with the Organized-Disorganized Model?
Little research has examined the model, raising doubts about its validity.
What are the three types of false confessions identified in Kassin and Kiechel's study?
Compliance, Internalization, and Confabulation.
What are some common motivations for crimes?
Passion, greed, or revenge.
What limitation does the Organized-Disorganized Model have regarding offender characteristics?
It cannot account for offenders who display a mixture of organized and disorganized features.
Who conducted the study on false confessions?
Saul M. Kassin and Katherine L. Kiechel.
What is the basic idea behind the Organized-Disorganized Model?
To profile the background characteristics of offenders based on the organization level of the crime scene.
What do geographic profiling systems do?
They utilize crime data to create profiles of offenders based on the geographic locations of their crimes.
What does the Court look for regarding the treatment of the suspect?
An atmosphere of oppression (unjust or inhumane treatment).
What could the wasted time from a false confession prevent?
Identifying and apprehending the real offender.
What is a major criticism of many criminal profiles?
They are so ambiguous that they can fit many suspects.
What challenges arise in crimes where the victim and offender are strangers?
It is more difficult to identify a suspect and there is often no clear motive.
What is the Reid Model of Interrogation?
A common nine-step method used in North America to extract confessions from suspects.
In which journal was Kassin and Kiechel's study on false confessions published?
Psychological Science.
What should an investigator do when encountering a disorganized crime scene?
Profile the background characteristics of a disorganized offender.
What is an example of an ambiguous prediction in criminal profiling?
The offender will be a 'social misfit'.
What do police rely on to gather details about crimes?
Witnesses, victims, and suspects.
What does the term 'operating mind' refer to in the context of a confession?
The suspect's awareness of what they were saying and who they were saying it to.
What are the three general stages of the Reid Model?
What is the accuracy level of geographic profiling systems?
Geographic profiling systems can be quite accurate.
What investigative technique do police often rely on for difficult cases?
Criminal profiling.
What year was the study on false confessions published?
What is the approach for organized crime scenes in the Organized-Disorganized Model?
Profile the background characteristics of organized offenders.
Why can't ambiguous profiles be used effectively in investigations?
Because they can be interpreted to fit a wide range of individuals, making it difficult to prioritize suspects.
What are the three types of false confessions?
Voluntary false confessions, coerced-compliant false confessions, and coerced-internalized false confessions.
What key details do police seek during investigations?
Who was involved, what happened, where and when it happened, how and why it happened.
What is the primary purpose of a police interrogation?
To gather evidence and obtain a confession.
What is a false confession?
A confession that is not true, often made under pressure or coercion.
What is the purpose of the non-accusatorial interview in the Reid Model?
To assess deception and determine if the suspect is lying about their innocence.
What is a weakness of the 'Alt-key' paradigm regarding false confessions?
There are no consequences for confessing.
What do studies of computerized geographic profiling systems indicate?
They can make accurate profiling predictions.
What must the Court consider about police trickery in obtaining a confession?
The degree of police trickery used, ensuring it does not 'shock the community.'
What is a voluntary false confession?
A confession made without any external pressure or coercion.
What is the final goal of the Reid Model of Interrogation?
To obtain a confession from the suspect.
What is another weakness of the 'Alt-key' paradigm?
All participants were innocent.
What are the three main types of false confessions?
Voluntary, coerced-compliant, and coerced-internalized.
What are the two main goals of police interrogations in North America?
To obtain a confession and to gain information that will further the investigation.
How is evidence often collected in police investigations?
Through interrogations of suspects.
What is a major criticism of professional profilers?
They may not be more accurate in their predictions than individuals without specialized training.
What is a voluntary false confession?
A confession that occurs without being prompted by the police.
How can geographic profiling predictions assist law enforcement?
These predictions are likely to assist the police.
What characterizes coerced-compliant false confessions?
Confessions made under pressure, where the individual complies to escape a stressful situation.
What confusion might participants experience in the 'Alt-key' paradigm?
They may be confused about their own guilt.
Why is there concern regarding coercive techniques in police interrogations?
Because of the power of confessions as evidence.
What is considered the most potent form of evidence in court?
Confession.
What characterizes a voluntary false confession?
A confession made willingly without external pressure.
What must police consider regarding statements made by professional profilers?
How much weight to put on those statements.
What are Miranda rights?
Safeguards assumed to protect individuals during interrogation, including the rights to silence and legal counsel.
What are some reasons for a voluntary false confession?
Desire for notoriety, inability to distinguish fact from fantasy, need to be punished, or attempt to protect the real offender.
What is the Reid Model of Interrogation?
A structured approach to interrogation that includes specific stages and techniques.
Why is geographic profiling not useful for traveling offenders?
Because they travel in a particular direction to commit their crimes.
What is the assumption made by investigators when moving from stage 2 to 3 of the Reid model?
That investigators can detect deception accurately.
What is a coerced-internalized false confession?
A confession where the individual comes to believe they committed the crime due to suggestive interrogation techniques.
What do new paradigms confirm about false confessions?
They confirm original findings.
What statistical technique was used by Goodwill et al. (2016) to study sex offenders?
Cluster analysis.
What is the primary goal of many police interrogations?
To generate a confession.
What does research indicate about the accuracy of professional profilers?
They do not always produce more accurate profiles than non-professionals under laboratory conditions.
What is a coerced-compliant false confession?
A confession made to escape a stressful situation or gain a benefit.
What does research indicate about people's understanding of their legal rights?
Many individuals often do not understand their rights when presented to them.
Can you provide an example of a case involving voluntary false confessions?
The Lindbergh case, where approximately 200 people made false confessions.
How do different profilers construct criminal profiles?
Profiles are constructed differently by different profilers, with various 'schools' of profiling guiding the process.
What are the Nine Steps of Reid?
A series of steps designed to elicit confessions from suspects during interrogations.
What is the Reid Model primarily used for?
Interrogation techniques.
For which type of offenders is geographic profiling typically useful?
For the majority of serial offenders who commit their crimes locally.
What does research say about the ability of investigators to detect deception?
Little research supports the assumption that investigators can accurately detect deception, even with specialized training.
What are the three clusters identified for victim selection by sex offenders?
How can false memories be induced according to the text?
Through suggestive interviews.
What does coerced-internalized false confession mean?
A confession where the individual comes to believe they committed the crime due to pressure.
What did Snook, Eastwood, et al. (2007) conclude about profilers' performance?
They demonstrate better performance, but not necessarily expert performance.
What types of tactics do interrogators use to generate confessions?
A variety of tactics, including psychologically coercive methods.
What is the first step of the Reid Model of Interrogation?
The suspect is immediately confronted with his or her guilt.
What is the challenge in defining criminal profiling?
It is difficult to define precisely.
What is known about the profiling process?
Relatively little is known about the profiling process, and descriptions provided by researchers and profilers are often vague.
What type of offender predominantly targets adult females with specific physical features?
Telio specific offenders.
Which groups are particularly likely to misunderstand their rights?
Juveniles and individuals with impaired intellectual capacity.
Do actual interrogations always include Reid techniques?
No, they do not always include Reid techniques.
What do Minimization and Maximization refer to in the Reid Model?
Techniques used to either downplay the seriousness of the situation or emphasize the consequences to encourage confessions.
What can be utilized for local serial offenders in investigations?
A number of profiling strategies.
How does the FBI define criminal profiling?
As a technique for identifying the personality and behavioral features of an individual based on an analysis of the crimes they have committed.
What are some consequences of false confessions?
Wrongful convictions, loss of trust in the justice system, and psychological harm to the confessor.
What is geographic profiling?
A technique used in investigations to analyze the locations of a series of crimes to identify the likely area where the offender resides.
What do current deception detection training programs, including Reid interrogation training, focus on?
Informing people about objective cues to deception.
What were historically used as coercive tactics in interrogations?
Physically coercive methods, such as whipping.
How can interrogators imply evidence against a suspect?
By hiding the fact that they do not have evidence and implying that such evidence exists.
What are the two main profiling methods discussed?
The deductive profiling method and the inductive profiling method.
What type of offender predominantly targets child and adolescent victims?
Pedo/hebe specific offenders.
What is one common technique used in the Reid Model?
Appealing to the suspect’s pride with flattery.
What contributes to the misunderstanding of Miranda rights?
The complex structure and language used in presenting these rights.
What are potential problems with the Reid Model?
Issues such as false confessions, coercion, and ethical concerns.
In what type of investigations was criminal profiling originally used?
In cases involving violent serial crime investigations.
What are some common characteristics profilers try to predict about an offender?
Age, sex, race, level of intelligence, educational history, hobbies, family background, residential location, criminal history, employment status, psychosexual development, and post-offence behaviour.
What is the popular term for the police interrogation technique used in the 1920s and 30s?
The third degree.
Why do police use criminal profiling?
To narrow down suspects and predict behaviors, but it can lead to potential problems such as bias and inaccuracies.
What is a characteristic of the deductive profiling method?
It involves reasoning from specific cases to general principles.
What do recent meta-analyses suggest about the utility of objective cues in deception detection?
They suggest that the training approach has limited utility because the cues are too weak to distinguish between truth-tellers and liars.
What is a false confession?
A confession that is either intentionally fabricated or not based on actual knowledge of the facts.
What are the three clusters of background characteristics identified in the study?
What psychological themes are developed in the Reid Model?
Themes that allow the suspect to rationalize or excuse the crime.
What has replaced physically coercive tactics in interrogations?
Psychologically coercive tactics, like lying about evidence.
What are some purposes of criminal profiles?
To help set traps for offenders, determine the seriousness of threats, provide interrogation advice, and inform prosecutors for cross-examination.
How do interrogators minimize the seriousness of the offense?
By downplaying the consequences to the suspect.
How can comprehension of legal rights be improved?
By delivering cautions in an appropriate format, such as written versus verbal.
What is a coerced-compliant false confession?
A confession resulting from a desire to escape a coercive interrogation or gain a promised benefit, where the confessor knows they did not commit the crime.
What is the role of procedural safeguards in interrogations?
To protect the rights of suspects and ensure fair interrogation practices.
Why do profilers consider an offender's educational history?
To understand their background and potential motivations.
What extreme methods were used during the third degree interrogation of Tony Colleti?
Continuous questioning, lying, threats, deprivation of food and water, physical abuse, and sleep deprivation.
What is a characteristic of the inductive profiling method?
It involves drawing generalizations from a large number of cases.
What is investigator bias in the context of interrogations?
It refers to officers entering the interrogation phase believing the suspect is guilty.
What type of interrogation may innocent suspects undergo?
Guilt-presumptive interrogation.
What are the three major types of false confessions?
Voluntary false confessions, coerced-compliant false confessions, and coerced-internalized false confessions.
How does the interrogator handle a suspect's denial?
By interrupting any statements of denial to prevent the suspect from gaining the upper hand.
What term does the RCMP prefer over 'profiling'?
Criminal investigative analysis.
What is the purpose of the Nine Steps of Reid?
To break down the suspect’s resistance to confessing.
How are coercive tactics often viewed in the context of interrogations?
As a necessary evil to convince guilty people to talk.
What is the importance of building rapport with a suspect?
It can lead to more confessions.
What tactics are often used by police to elicit coerced-compliant false confessions?
Coercive interrogation tactics, such as maximization and minimization techniques.
How does an offender's family background contribute to profiling?
It provides insights into their upbringing and possible influences on behaviour.
What happened to Tony Colleti before his trial?
He hanged himself in jail.
How can investigator bias affect interrogations?
It can lead to unfair treatment of suspects and influence the outcome of the interrogation.
What can contribute to the likelihood of false confessions?
Coercive interrogation tactics.
How does investigator bias affect the interpretation of information during interrogations?
Officers may seek out and interpret information in a way that verifies their initial belief of guilt.
What is done if a suspect becomes withdrawn during interrogation?
The interrogator ensures they have the suspect's attention and uses techniques to reduce psychological distance.
Why have many agencies moved away from the term 'profiling'?
To suggest a broader focus that includes more than just making predictions about an offender's background.
What is one problem with the Reid model of interrogation?
It can lead to high rates of false confessions due to its confrontational nature.
What is the first step in the Nine Steps of Reid?
Direct statement of belief in the suspect’s guilt.
What tactic involves sympathizing with the suspect?
Condemning others to create a bond.
What are geographic profiling systems?
Computer systems that use mathematical models of offender spatial behavior to predict where unknown serial offenders are likely to reside.
What is a coerced-internalized false confession?
A confession that results from suggestive interrogations, where the confessor comes to believe they committed the crime.
What is the significance of the case R. v. M.J.S. (2000)?
It illustrates a potential coerced-compliant false confession, where M.J.S. confessed to aggravated assault on his son but may not have been responsible for the crime.
What role does an offender's criminal history play in profiling?
It helps in predicting future behaviour and understanding patterns.
Why would a confession obtained through the third degree be considered inadmissible in court?
Because it is considered oppressive.
What are alternatives to the Reid Model?
Different interrogation techniques that may be more ethical or effective.
What technique can be used to keep a suspect engaged in the interrogation?
Physically moving closer to the suspect.
What is the classic trait model in personality profiling?
A model that assumes stable, internal traits are the primary determinants of behavior.
What tactics were historically used to extract confessions from suspects?
Physically coercive tactics.
How can criminal profiles assist in interrogation?
By providing advice on how to approach the interrogation process.
What are some consequences of investigator bias during interrogations?
Leads to biased perceptions, more guilt-presumptive questions, and increased pressure on suspects.
What does the second step of the Reid technique involve?
Developing and introducing psychological themes.
Name another problem with the Reid model of interrogation.
It may create a psychological pressure that can overwhelm suspects, leading to unreliable confessions.
How does a retracted confession differ from a false confession?
A retracted confession is one that the confessor later declares to be false, regardless of its actual truth.
What is a noted gap in research regarding the Reid Model?
Lack of direct research using real-world data.
How do geographic profiling systems represent crime sites?
As points on a map based on linked crime locations.
What interrogation technique is often associated with coerced-internalized false confessions?
Minimization techniques.
Why might coerced-compliant false confessions be considered common?
They often arise from the pressure of coercive interrogation environments.
What significant event in 1888 involved early attempts at criminal profiling?
The Jack the Ripper murders.
Why is psychosexual development important in profiling?
It can reveal motivations and behaviours related to sexual offences.
What is geographic profiling?
An analysis of crime scene locations to determine the most probable area of offender residence.
How do modern interrogation techniques differ from the third degree?
They rely more on psychological approaches rather than physical coercion.
What does the classic trait model assume about behavior patterns?
It assumes that consistent patterns of behavior persist over time and across situations.
What is one example of assessing the seriousness of a threat using profiling?
Determining whether a threatening note should be taken seriously.
What was one example of a coercive tactic used in the mid-twentieth century?
Whipping, as seen in Brown v. Mississippi (1936).
What is a disputed confession?
A confession that is later disputed at trial, which does not necessarily mean it is false or retracted.
How does the Reid technique suggest handling a suspect's denial?
By interrupting statements of denial.
What did research by Kassin et al. (2003) reveal about investigative biases?
It indicated that biases led to coercive interrogations, making suspects appear guiltier even if they committed no crime.
What is a third problem with the Reid model of interrogation?
It often relies on subjective judgment, which can introduce investigator bias.
Who was Dr. George Phillips?
A police surgeon involved in the Jack the Ripper investigation who engaged in criminal profiling.
What is an example of a coerced-compliant false confession?
M.J.S.'s confession to child abuse in the case R. v. M.J.S. (2000).
Who decides on the admissibility of confession evidence in North American courts?
The trial judge.
What do geographic profiling systems calculate?
The probability that an offender lives at particular points in the area where the offenses have taken place.
What assumption does geographic profiling make about offenders?
Offenders do not travel long distances from home to commit the majority of their crimes.
What is the focus of investigative psychology approaches in profiling?
They emphasize rigorously testing the validity of proposed categories and the linkage between crime scene behaviors and background characteristics.
What are some vulnerability factors associated with coerced-internalized false confessions?
History of substance abuse, inability to detect discrepancies, and factors related to mental state such as severe anxiety or confusion.
How does the classic trait model apply to criminal profiling?
It suggests that an offender's internal traits influence their criminal behavior and noncriminal lifestyle.
What type of interrogation tactics were used by Chicago police in the 1970s and 80s?
A wide range of torture tactics.
What is the goal of presenting the alternative question in the Reid technique?
To guide the suspect towards admitting guilt.
How do biased interrogators behave towards suspects?
They judge more suspects as guilty and exert more pressure to confess.
What is one psychological tactic used in modern interrogations?
The presentation of false evidence.
What was the focus of Kassin and Kiechel’s ALT key experiment?
To study false confessions under various conditions.
What method did Dr. George Phillips use to profile the offender in the Jack the Ripper case?
Circumspect examination of the wound patterns of murder victims.
What is known about the frequency of false confessions?
The frequency of false confessions is unknown but they are common in high-profile wrongful convictions.
What is the purpose of laboratory studies on false confessions?
To understand the nature of false confessions.
What are the key issues a judge must consider regarding a questionable confession?
Whether the confession was made voluntarily and if the defendant was competent.
What does research indicate about serial offenders and their crime site selection?
Serial offenders tend to commit their crimes very close to where they reside.
How is the probability of an offender's residence represented on the map?
Each location is assigned an overall probability and designated a color.
What impact does investigator bias have on neutral observers of interrogations?
Observers rate the interrogations as more coercive.
Why might individuals with brain impairments be more susceptible to coerced-internalized false confessions?
They may have difficulty detecting discrepancies between their observations and erroneous suggestions.
What is a major flaw of the classic trait model?
It incorrectly assumes that internal traits are the sole determinants of behavior, ignoring situational influences.
What is the final step in the Nine Steps of Reid?
Turning oral confession into a written confession.
What was the financial consequence for the City of Chicago due to the use of torture tactics?
The city paid out millions of dollars in settlements.
How do investigative psychology approaches differ from previous inductive approaches?
They place more emphasis on testing the validity of categories rather than just relying on previously solved cases.
What was the outcome of Dr. James Brussel's profiling of the Mad Bomber in New York City?
His profile matched the actual suspect, George Metesky.
What does compliance refer to in the context of false confessions?
A tendency to go along with demands made by authority figures.
What makes confessions more likely to be unreliable?
Involuntary confessions and those provided when a person's mind is unstable.
What ethical constraint is faced in laboratory studies of false confessions?
Making someone believe they committed a horrible crime.
What are the two categories of an offender's background characteristics in the Organized-Disorganized Model?
Organized (methodical) and disorganized (disturbed).
How can situational factors affect criminal behavior according to the text?
Situational factors can create behavioral inconsistencies, complicating the profiling process.
What model is similar to the inductive approaches proposed by investigative psychology?
The organized-disorganized model.
How is geographic profiling used in investigations?
Primarily for prioritizing potential suspects based on their proximity to the predicted home location.
What notable detail did Dr. James Brussel include in his profile of the Mad Bomber?
The suspect wore a double-breasted suit.
What mental states can increase susceptibility to coerced-internalized false confessions?
Severe anxiety, confusion, or feelings of guilt.
What does a colored map output from geographic profiling systems indicate?
The probability that the offender lives in different areas, with color bands corresponding to different probability levels.
